Interview

Making education data accessible: Q&A with the Pakistan Coalition for Education

Ⓒ Pakistan Coalition for Education

Across the world, Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) are turning to digital technologies, transparency portals, monitoring platforms, and whistleblower systems to increase transparency and accountability in education. From Pakistan, Zehra Arshad shares insights on the Pakistan Coalition for Education Data Portal, which gives users reader-friendly access to core education data on key themes and indicators across districts and provinces.

Could you tell us about your background and your work with the Pakistan Coalition for Education Data Portal?

Zehra Arshad: I’m working as National Coordinator of the Pakistan Coalition for Education and also leading the Society for Access to Quality Education. The work our network is doing is about building the capacities of marginalized stakeholders, bringing youth voices and marginalized voices into education policy processes. It’s a kind of movement around education as a public good and fundamental right, and how much this translates into action.

We look at how civil society stakeholders are engaged, the transparency and accountability of government institutions, and whether there is enough financing to bring every child to school. For more than 20 years, I have been working with this coalition and bringing the voices of marginalized communities into the education sector.

Ⓒ Pakistan Coalition for Education

Why was the Data Portal launched in 2020? 

Zehra Arshad: We started this Data Portal during COVID because we thought one of the major issues was that we didn’t have the data. If your discussions and demands are not backed by data, it will be difficult to justify your voices, demands, and recommendations. What we have done is that we were the first to try to consolidate the data in a reader-friendly form for everybody. Whether you are a student, a think tank, or a policy-maker, you can go to our Data Portal and get the data. It’s a common platform where we bring together education-related data for the use of common people, for transparency and accountability.

Looking back, what have been some of the portal’s biggest successes? 

Zehra Arshad: When we started this Data Portal, we were inspired by the UNESCO Institute for Statistics (UIS) Data Portal. We would love to have that kind of active, engaging portal where you can get different datasets with one command. We tried it, but it requires lots of resources and continuous support. Due to resource constraints, what we did was consolidate the data that we have. We developed the infographics in a reader-friendly manner so that people could understand them, and we have uploaded them. 

We have data on education financing, including organizational studies and government data, and you will find that there is a similarity of patterns. This helps strengthen civil society and government initiatives and helps civil society raise concerns. This has created a movement around domestic resource mobilization and education financing. 

We cannot claim that it is only because of our Data Portal, but the data is very important. When stakeholders, activists, and think tanks talk about spending less than 3% of GDP on education, these concerns can ultimately be raised in parliamentary forums. We think this is one of the successes.

In Pakistan, where there are many political issues and discontinuity of policies when governments change, it is always like one step ahead and three steps backward. These are small wins, but very important ones for education governance, transparency, and accountability.

What challenges do you face in making education data available?

Zehra Arshad: The availability of data itself is a challenge. There are a lot of countries that don’t have data, and the same is true in Pakistan. There is also a difference between data collected by provinces and data collected at the national level. There are differences in the figures, and questions about which figure is right and which is wrong. 

The other challenge is the credibility of the data. If district or provincial data is available, national statistics may not take it into account. Data linked to education spending and government accountability is sometimes not available or, if available, is not publicly accessible.

Why are international studies on digital tools and education accountability important? 

Zehra Arshad: These studies are very important, but there are lots of questions around contextualization. We are a country where more than 50% of the population is living below the poverty line. In that scenario, how can the education system be made accessible to people living in extreme poverty? 

If we are talking about AI or digital learning, we need to consider access to these tools and the safeguarding policies required. We need context-specific information that can contribute to a comprehensive global agenda. These studies should not be a one-time activity. They should be continuous if you need to dig deeper into these issues and make them relevant.

What are the issues the Global South is facing? And how does this whole agenda for education tech, AI, digital education, what differences they can make into their lives or the country at the country level. These are issues that require a very rigorous amount of studies, which should be coming out on a regular basis.  

Which digital tools are you currently watching, and how could they help you further develop the Data Portal? 

Zehra Arshad: We are revamping our Data Portal. We are working on how AI-powered features can become part of it, how we can make it more interactive, and how data can be made available in different forms.

It is important that the data is reader-friendly and easy for civil society to understand. If students or parents want to use it, they should be able to. We are trying to revamp the portal so that it can be utilized by multiple stakeholders.

Can you share an example of data contributing to action on making education more accountable? 

Zehra Arshad: Out-of-school children and girls’ education are major issues in Pakistan. Our study on investment in girls’ education looks at how much financing is required to bring girls into schools. This gained momentum because the figures and information are available and everybody is talking about it. In some provinces, additional resources are being directed towards girls’ education, so that is some of the work we have started. Provinces are also introducing gender-based budgeting, providing 70% to schools with girls and 30% to other schools. We cannot claim that this belongs to us alone, but our studies are on the Data Portal, and they help translate these things very openly.

Learn more about the Pakistan case and six other initiatives in Benin, Mozambique, two in Nigeria, South Africa, and The Gambia:

Read IIEP's publication